Skip to content
Field notes / Payroll and compliance

Certified payroll service vs software: which does a contractor need?

Compare a certified payroll service, a payroll system with certified reports, a reporting tool and a GC collection platform, with published prices and who each fits.

By Buildalytic editorial team2 min read

Editorial scene of payroll records and classifications
Illustrative editorial scene, not a vendor test.
The short answer

A certified payroll service runs your payroll and files the reports for you, which suits a contractor without payroll staff. Software suits a contractor who already runs payroll and needs correct WH-347s and state files. A general contractor collecting subcontractors' payrolls needs a collection and review platform such as Buildalytic, LCPtracker Pro or eMars, not a payroll service.

What to take away

  • Payroll service: someone else runs payroll and reports.
  • Reporting software: you run payroll, it makes the reports.
  • Collection platform: a GC gathers and checks every sub's reports.

Four ways to handle certified payroll

Published prices were checked on each vendor's own site on November 11, 2026.

Four ways to handle certified payroll
ApproachExamplesWho it fitsPublished price
Payroll servicePayroll4Construction, Points North managed serviceNo in-house payroll staffQuote
Payroll system with certified reportseBacon, Miter, FoundationIn-house payroll with many prevailing wage jobsDemo or custom
Reporting toolWeeklyCertified, CertifiedPayrollPro, LCPcertifiedPayroll already run elsewhereFree to $249 a month; $12 a report
GC collection and reviewBuildalytic, LCPtracker Pro, eMarsPrimes and agencies with many subcontractorsQuoted per project or demo

Sources: Payroll4Construction: certified payroll (checked November 11, 2026); Points North: certified payroll reporting (checked November 11, 2026); eBacon: prevailing wage payroll (checked November 11, 2026); Miter: certified payroll (checked November 11, 2026); Foundation Software: certified payroll (checked November 11, 2026); WeeklyCertified: pricing (checked November 11, 2026); CertifiedPayrollPro: pricing (checked November 11, 2026); LCPtracker: LCPcertified (checked November 11, 2026); LCPtracker: LCPtracker Pro (checked November 11, 2026); eMars: certified payroll software (checked November 11, 2026); Buildalytic: collect subcontractor payrolls

A subcontractor with 12 field workers

If payroll already runs in your accounting system, a reporting tool is usually enough: at published prices that is $0 to $99 a month. If nobody in the office is comfortable with prevailing wage payroll, a service or payroll system is worth the higher, quoted price because the fringe and overtime math is done once, in payroll.

A general contractor with 20 subcontractors

Here the hard part is not producing your own WH-347; it is getting 20 employers' payrolls every week and checking them. A collection and review platform tracks who is missing, flags issues and keeps corrections with the week. Buildalytic adds Brody's follow-up calls and texts to the subs who are late.

Common questions

Is a certified payroll service worth it?

It is worth it when nobody in-house runs prevailing wage payroll confidently. If you already run payroll, reporting software costs less.

Can a payroll service collect my subcontractors' certified payrolls?

Payroll services report for their own clients' employees. To collect and review subcontractors' payrolls, use a collection platform such as Buildalytic, LCPtracker Pro or eMars.

Sources and editorial notes

Prepared with AI assistance. Reference date: 2026-11-11. Worked examples are illustrative and are not customer results. Product details can change; confirm the current scope and terms before rollout.

How we prepare and update field notes
See it on your workflow

Collect and check every sub's payroll.

Bring one project and its subcontractor list. See how missing payrolls are followed up and how each finding is reviewed.

Start with the call, text or record your team already handles. Review the expected outcome and the human handoff before choosing a rollout.

Talk to the payroll team Explore the relevant capability